SUSHI-Society for US Intellectual History

Main menu

Skip to primary content
Skip to secondary content
  • About Us
  • Governance
  • Join
  • Resources

Post navigation

← Older posts
U.S. Intellectual History Blog

Category Archives: .USIH Blog

All USIH blogs

Post navigation

← Older posts

Livingston: The Assumptions That Drive Our Discipline

Posted on June 18, 2013 by L.D. Burnett
3

by James Livingston

[Editor's note: this guest post by James Livingston is a response to the conversation initiated by Ben Alpers's post from yesterday, "An Unusable Past." --LDB]

Ben, Tim, and Kurt are right, I have been unconsciously questioning the assumptions that drive our discipline, at least as it’s presently constituted in the universities of the USA.

My unkind “review” of Paul Murphy’s book was a symptom of my frustration with what I see as historians’ unwarranted complacence in view of epistemic revolutions all around.  American historians tend to focus on the “good guys”—the exceptions to the rule of capital—and thus reduce the past to the heroic moments of “resistance.”  This usable past becomes the exception to the exception, a miracle that can’t be reproduced.  So it becomes an icon rather than a text, something to be worshipped rather than parsed.  The Pops, the Communists, SDS, those were the days.  Enter, stage left, Howard Zinn. Continue reading →

Posted in .USIH Blog, guest post, historians, historical memory, historical theory, historiography, History, James Livingston | 3 Replies

A History of Color-blindness and Memory of Civil Rights

Posted on June 18, 2013 by Andrew Hartman
3

The following is a guest post from Robert Greene II, a PhD student in History at the University of South Carolina. This is Greene’s second guest post for the USIH Blog. His first: “Why I Chose Intellectual History”

As historians, we often find ourselves digesting not just the past, but how it relates to the present. To that end, a research question I find myself coming back to is, “How did conservatives and liberals come to the positions they’ve taken on race?” Initially such a question appears easy to answer. Scratching beneath the surface, however, forces Americanists to take a closer look at not just the transition in thought on race amongst intellectuals and academics after the Second World War (chronicled most notably in Richard King’s Race, Culture, and the Intellectuals) [1] but the adjustment of liberals and conservatives to a new racial outlook in American society after the Civil Rights Movement, when blatant racism was no longer politically palatable. This would include, of course, Democrats (and new Republicans) in the South, figures such as George Wallace and Strom Thurmond. Being some of the most notable opponents of integration in the 1960s, they would have to adjust to a new reality to continue to win office in the 1970s and beyond.MLK_Memorial_NPS_photo

The transition made in the 1970s for many Southern conservatives from opposition to the Civil Rights Act and Voting Rights Act, to supporting the renewal of the VRA and backing the creation of the Martin Luther King, Jr. holiday only makes sense once you consider the power of public memory. A memory of accepting African Americans fully into the body politic was necessary, but at the same time, conservatives would not countenance such liberal remedies for institutional racism as affirmative action. A vigorous, renewed debate over ideas of race and identity has taken place in the United States since the passage of the Voting Rights Act of 1965. However, this new debate would include the idea of color-blindness, something conservatives would immediately latch on to. Continue reading →

Posted in .USIH Blog, guest post, race, Robert Greene II | 3 Replies

An Unusable Past?

Posted on June 17, 2013 by Ben_Alpers
15

Although the phrase “a usable past” was coined by Van Wyck Brooks in the 1910s and has been embraced by scholars of a variety of political stripes in the decades since, for the last half century or so, it’s often been closely associated with radical historians of the United States, who have looked to ideas and social movements from the American past as to guide their contemporaries, in various ways, toward a brighter future.

So I was quite struck when, in the last couple days, I’ve encountered three scholars on the left who, in quite different ways, have recently suggested that the past may not be as usable as we once thought. Continue reading →

Posted in .USIH Blog, Edward Snowden, Gar Alperovitz, government surveillance, James Livingston, Peter Ludlow, usable past | 15 Replies

Post navigation

← Older posts
SUSHI-Society for US Intellectual History
  • RSS
  • Twitter
  • Facebook
  • All text (including posts, pages, and comments) posted on this blog on or after August 7, 2012, is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial-ShareAlike 3.0 Unported License. More information here

    This blog is © 2007-2013 Society for U.S. Intellectual History.

  • The Society for U.S. Intellectual History is a nonprofit, nonpartisan educational organization. The opinions expressed on the blog are strictly those of the individual writers and do not represent those of the Society or of the writers' employers.
  • Recent Comments

    • Bill Barnes on Livingston: The Assumptions That Drive Our Discipline
    • L.D. Burnett on Livingston: The Assumptions That Drive Our Discipline
    • Tim Lacy on Livingston: The Assumptions That Drive Our Discipline
    • Tim Lacy on An Unusable Past?
    • Dan Wickberg on An Unusable Past?
  • Categories

  • Archives

  • Tweet Blender

    Twitter Logo
    Refresh
    burnidgeburnidge: RT @HartmanAndrew: I write on masculinity & culture wars, discuss Susan Faludi's book STIFFED & Promise Keepers. http://t.co/Vvjwgvm7hg #twitterstorians #USIH
    1 week ago from TweetDeck
    reply | follow burnidge
    rbfelixrbfelix: RT @HartmanAndrew: I write on masculinity & culture wars, discuss Susan Faludi's book STIFFED & Promise Keepers. http://t.co/Vvjwgvm7hg #twitterstorians #USIH
    1 week ago from Twitter for iPhone
    reply | follow rbfelix
    HartmanAndrewHartmanAndrew: I write on masculinity & culture wars, discuss Susan Faludi's book STIFFED & Promise Keepers. http://t.co/Vvjwgvm7hg #twitterstorians #USIH
    1 week ago from web
    reply | follow HartmanAndrew
    HartmanAndrewHartmanAndrew: "Beer and cigars for everyone!" -- @LDBurnett http://t.co/wHmoXh3pqx #USIH
    1 week ago from web
    reply | follow HartmanAndrew
  • Contact us: s-usih@s-usih.org